Relay transport¶
The relay layer handles everything below the application protocol: WebSocket connectivity, message encryption, reconnection, and message queuing. Application code (wallet, dapp) should never touch nostr-tools or Nostr directly.
Stack¶
Application messages (ProtocolMessage JSON)
↓ JSON.stringify
PrivateDirectMessage (kind 14, unsigned rumor)
↓ sender-signed seal (kind 13, NIP-44 encrypted to recipient)
↓ NIP-59 gift wrap (kind 1059, encrypted to recipient)
nostr-tools SimplePool → Nostr relay (WebSocket)
↓ stored as kind 1059 event, tagged with recipient pubkey
nostr-tools SimplePool ← subscription (kind=1059, #p=<our_pubkey>)
↓ verify wrap → decrypt seal → verify seal → decrypt rumor → validate
Application message handler
RelayClient¶
RelayClient is the low-level building block. One instance per peer connection.
Responsibilities¶
- Owns a nostr-tools
SimplePoolconfigured with explicit relay URLs. - Subscribes to
kind:1059(GiftWrap) events tagged with its own pubkey. - Verifies the outer wrap and inner kind-13 seal before accepting the decrypted rumor.
- Requires the rumor author to match the signed seal author and the pinned peer.
- Publishes outbound messages using NIP-59
wrapEventaddressed to the paired peer. - Validates application envelope shape and timestamp before changing the replay cutoff.
- Discards messages older than
lastProcessedTimestamp(best-effort replay filtering). - Queues outbound messages until at least one relay is ready.
Construction¶
new RelayClient({
explicitRelayUrls: string[]; // WebSocket URLs, e.g. ["wss://relay.riften.net:443"]
signerPrivateKey: Uint8Array; // 32-byte secp256k1 private key (this client's identity)
pairedPublicKey?: Uint8Array; // 32-byte x-only pubkey of the peer (set after key exchange)
logNetworkActivity?: boolean; // default true
})
Key methods¶
connect(): Promise<void>
// Close any existing subscription, then subscribe to GiftWrap events and wait for relays.
disconnect(): Promise<void>
// Stop subscription, close the relay pool, mark queue not-ready, update
// lastProcessedTimestamp. Kills any in-flight publish — see below.
relay(message: ProtocolMessage): Promise<void>
// Send a message. Enqueues if relays not ready. Throws if paired key not set.
// Resolves only once the publish has settled against every configured relay.
setPairedPublicKey(key: Uint8Array): void
// Called after key exchange. Enables outbound messages and incoming peer filtering.
isKeyExchangeComplete(): boolean
// true once pairedPublicKey is set and non-zero.
nextSequence(): number
// Returns a unique sequence number (starts at random offset, increments by 2).
getLastProcessedTimestamp(): number
setLastProcessedTimestamp(ts: number): void
// Read/restore a best-effort cutoff; accepts any finite number >= 0 (Unix seconds).
Message queue¶
Before any relay is confirmed as connected, outbound relay() calls are enqueued in a
MessageQueue. The client polls every 100 ms for up to 5 seconds for at least one relay with
status 1 (connected). After that timeout it assumes the relay is ready and flushes the queue
regardless (avoiding silent message loss on slow connections).
On disconnect(), the queue is marked not-ready so messages sent during a reconnect gap are
held rather than dropped.
Because disconnect() closes the pool, it kills any publish still in flight — so anything
sending a final message before tearing down must await the relay() first. See
wallet.md § Sending disconnect.
Replay protection¶
Application messages must be objects with a nonempty string action and a positive, finite
Unix-seconds time. The outer wrap and seal timestamps are randomized by NIP-59 and are not
replay cutoffs. Only messages from the pinned peer advance the cutoff, so a peer whose clock
runs ahead affects only its own pairing.
lastProcessedTimestamp starts at now - 2 on first connection. Accepted messages from the
pinned peer advance it monotonically, and disconnect() advances it to at least now.
The cutoff is cached per local/peer key pair across instance recreation within the same JS
session. Changing the pinned peer clears partial chunk buffers and restores that pair's
own cutoff instead of inheriting the previous peer's. Restoring a cutoff rejects nonfinite or
negative values.
Messages with time < lastProcessedTimestamp are dropped, including out-of-order older
messages. Equal-second messages remain eligible so multiple messages and chunks sent in one
second work. This is not an exactly-once guarantee or a durable application replay journal:
equal-second replays can pass, and the cache does not survive process restart. Applications
that release signatures or authorize irreversible actions must enforce their own persisted
message identity, expiry, and conflict journal.
Before pairing, only authenticated wallet_ready messages with public_key equal to the seal
author are delivered. They do not advance the cutoff: the dapp must still validate its shared
pairing secret before calling setPairedPublicKey(). Once pinned, wallet_ready has no
unknown-peer exception and cannot replace the peer identity. Reassembled messages undergo
the same envelope/timestamp validation before application dispatch.
With logNetworkActivity enabled, dropped messages log the reason without message content:
invalid envelopes, unknown peers, or a timestamp older than the cutoff (including both times).
Unreadable or invalid gift wraps are logged and dropped without emitting "error" or starting
a reconnect. Transport failures still follow the disconnect/reconnect path described below.
Keepalive¶
RelayClient creates its SimplePool with enablePing: true. This enables nostr-tools'
built-in heartbeat: every 29 seconds the pool pings each connected relay and expects a
response within 20 seconds. In Node.js this uses native WebSocket ping/pong frames; in
browsers (where the WebSocket API doesn't expose ping) it falls back to sending a dummy
subscription request and waiting for EOSE.
If a relay fails to respond, nostr-tools closes the WebSocket, which fires the subscription
onclose callback, which emits "disconnect" on RelayClient, which triggers the
connection manager's existing reconnect loop. This detects "zombie" TCP connections where the
socket appears open but the relay is unreachable.
Additionally, if a publishMessage() call fails (all relays reject the event),
RelayClient emits "disconnect" alongside the thrown error. This ensures the reconnect
loop starts immediately rather than waiting for the next ping cycle.
Sequence numbers¶
nextSequence() starts at a random offset in the safe integer range and increments by 2. This
means two instances are unlikely to collide (they start at different offsets), and the step of 2
leaves room for error responses at odd offsets if needed in the future.
initiateRelay¶
initiateRelay() (in relay-handler.ts) wraps RelayClient with a reconnect loop:
initiateRelay(
statusCallback: RelayStatusCallback,
privateKey: Uint8Array,
initialPairedKey: Uint8Array,
options: { explicitRelayUrls, reconnectInterval?, maxReconnectAttempts? }
): () => void // returns cleanup function
It calls statusCallback with a RelayUpdatePayload on every state change:
interface RelayUpdatePayload {
client: RelayClient;
status: RelayStatus; // { status: "connected" | "reconnecting" | "disconnected" }
}
The reconnect loop is simple: on a disconnect event from the client it waits
reconnectInterval (default 5000 ms) and calls client.connect() again. No exponential backoff
currently — connections are expected to be stable (relay and mobile network) and fast to re-establish.
initiateDappRelay¶
Higher-level helper that bundles credential generation, URI encoding, key exchange handling, and reconnection into one call:
initiateDappRelay(
statusCallback: RelayStatusCallback,
options?: {
explicitRelayUrls?: string[];
reconnectInterval?: number;
maxReconnectAttempts?: number;
existingCredentials?: { privateKey: string; secret: string };
}
): DappRelayResult
interface DappRelayResult {
client: RelayClient;
uri: string; // wiz:// URI to encode into QR
credentials: KeyExchangeCredentials;
events: EventEmitter<{ keyexchangecomplete: [walletPublicKey: Uint8Array] }>;
cleanup: () => void;
}
Internally it wraps the caller's statusCallback to intercept wallet_ready messages,
verify the secret, and call client.setPairedPublicKey() before the message is processed by
DappConnectionManager. On reconnect, if walletPublicKeyNostr is already known it immediately
restores the paired key so outbound messages can be sent before the next wallet_ready arrives.
initiateWalletRelay¶
initiateWalletRelay(
statusCallback: RelayStatusCallback,
options: {
uri: string; // wiz:// URI from QR scan
walletPrivateKey: Uint8Array; // stable relay identity key for this connection URI
}
): { cleanup: () => void }
The wallet MUST reuse one relay key per connection URI, derived from its seed and the URI
or persisted with the URI. A paired dapp ignores messages from any other key, including
wallet_ready. If the wallet changes key, it must obtain a fresh URI from a new dapp pairing
(reload the dapp rather than resuming the old pairing).
Decodes the URI, sets the dapp's public key as the initial paired key, and starts the relay.
On each connect/reconnect, the wallet sends wallet_ready which carries the key exchange fields
(public_key, secret) alongside the session data. This gives the dapp the wallet's pubkey
atomically with the application handshake data.
Encryption: NIP-17 gift wrap¶
NIP-17 gift wrap works like a sealed envelope:
- Rumor (kind 14,
PrivateDirectMessage): the unsigned plaintext message. Content is the JSON payload. Tags include["p", recipient_pubkey_hex]. - Seal (kind 13): the rumor encrypted with NIP-44 using the sender's private key and
recipient's public key, then signed by the sender. No
ptag. - Wrap (kind 1059,
GiftWrap): the seal encrypted to the recipient's public key using a freshly generated throwaway key, then signed by that key. Has a recipientptag.
The relay sees only kind 1059 with a recipient tag. It cannot read content or link messages to senders. The throwaway outer key means even the relay cannot correlate multiple messages from the same sender.
Outbound wrapping uses nostr-tools wrapEvent(). On receipt, RelayClient uses nostr-tools'
NIP-44 decryption and event verification APIs to verify each signed layer and require the
seal author, rumor author and pinned peer to match before dispatch or cutoff changes.
Default relays¶
Both relays are used by default on both dapp and wallet sides for redundancy. Since Nostr relays do not federate (they don't forward events to each other), connecting to multiple relays ensures messages are delivered even if one relay is temporarily unavailable.
The connection URI encodes only the primary relay; the secondary is added programmatically
by the library. When a custom relay is specified (via URI or explicitRelayUrls), only that
relay is used — default relays are not auto-added.
Nothing in the protocol prevents using any other standard Nostr relay.
Duplicate message handling¶
When subscribed to multiple relays, the same event may arrive from more than one relay.
nostr-tools SimplePool.subscribeMany() deduplicates events by ID — it tracks seen event IDs
in a per-subscription _knownIds set and only fires onevent once per unique ID. Since
pool.publish(urls, event) sends the identical event (same ID) to all relays, the receiving
side's pool delivers it exactly once.
Transport-level extensions¶
Transport-level extensions are capabilities of the relay/gift-wrap transport itself, independent
of any application protocol. They're distinct from the protocol-level extensions documented in
extensions.md, which extend hdwalletv1 specifically.
Negotiation¶
Both sides advertise transport-level extensions in a base extensions field on their handshake
message (dapp_ready / wallet_ready). The shape is identical on both sides:
interface DappReadyMessage {
// ...
extensions?: Record<string, unknown>;
}
interface WalletReadyMessage {
// ...
extensions?: Record<string, unknown>;
}
A capability is considered enabled only when both sides advertise it. RelayClient exposes
setPeerCapabilities({...}) so the connection managers can inform it once they've parsed the
peer's _ready message.
Extension values are per-extension; today chunk uses { version: 1 }. Unknown extension keys
are ignored by implementations that don't recognise them, so adding new capabilities is always
backward-compatible — an old peer simply doesn't advertise them and the new side falls back to
the non-extended behaviour.
Known transport extensions¶
| Extension | Purpose |
|---|---|
chunk |
Split messages larger than NIP-44's 65,535-byte plaintext ceiling across multiple gift-wrapped events. Symmetric — enabled when both sides advertise. See below. |
Chunking (chunk extension)¶
Why it exists¶
NIP-44 caps plaintext at 65,535 bytes — the length is encoded as a U16BE prefix in the wire
format, so the limit is structural, not a guardrail that can be raised. NIP-17 gift-wrap
additionally encrypts twice (rumor inside seal inside wrap), so a single 50+ KB ProtocolMessage
will blow the outer wrap's plaintext budget even when the inner payload itself looks small enough.
Real scenarios that exceed the cap:
- Aggregated swap
sign_transaction_requestwith many pool UTXOs (each with hexlockingBytecodeandunlockingBytecodein the per-inputsourceOutputs). sign_transaction_responsecarrying a signed transaction hex string. Policy-max BCH transactions are 100 KB (→ 200 KB hex); consensus-max is 1 MB (→ 2 MB hex).
Wire format¶
interface ChunkMessage extends ProtocolMessage {
action: "chunk";
time: number; // shared across all chunks of one logical message
msgId: string; // random identifier, shared across all chunks
index: number; // 0-based chunk index within [0, total)
total: number; // total number of chunks for this msgId
data: string; // base64 slice of the UTF-8 bytes of JSON.stringify(originalMessage)
}
To reconstruct the original message: concatenate the data strings in index order, base64-decode
to bytes, UTF-8-decode to a string, JSON.parse.
Sender¶
RelayClient.publishMessage measures the UTF-8 byte length of the serialized ProtocolMessage.
If it exceeds the per-message threshold:
- If the peer's
chunkcapability is enabled, the message is split intoChunkMessages and each is published individually via the samewrapEventpath as any other message. No ACKs — see "Failure modes" below. - If the peer has not advertised
chunk,publishMessagethrows a structured error ("Cannot send <action>: message is larger than NIP-44's 65,535-byte ceiling and the peer does not advertise the 'chunk' transport extension. Please update the connected wallet/dapp..."). This replaces the crypticinvalid plaintext sizeerror from nostr-tools.
The per-chunk budget is sized conservatively. Each chunk's raw data is ≤ 30,000 bytes, which after
base64 expansion (~4/3×), JSON envelope overhead, and the two-layer NIP-17 gift-wrap encryption
stays well under NIP-44's 65,535-byte ceiling for the outer wrap's plaintext. See
packages/core/src/transforms/chunk.ts for the derivation.
Receiver¶
RelayClient owns a ChunkReassembler instance. Chunks pass the same peer filter and
lastProcessedTimestamp dedup as any other message, then are routed to the reassembler. When all
chunks for a msgId have arrived (in any order), the bytes are concatenated, decoded, and the
resulting ProtocolMessage is handed to the application-level handler — indistinguishable to
the application from an unchunked message of equivalent size.
The reassembler holds two maps with TTL eviction:
- in-flight buffers keyed by
msgId— collects chunks until complete; default TTL 120 s, sized to comfortably fit a ~35-chunk 2 MB response under real relay latency. - completed — tracks
msgIds we've already delivered, for the same TTL, so late-arriving duplicates (e.g. cross-subscription replay after reconnect) don't spawn a second reassembly and double-deliver.
A background sweeper runs every 10 s while connected and evicts expired entries. Reassembly state is not persisted — reconnects rely on the relay replaying events to complete any in-flight transfer (see below).
Failure modes¶
| Failure | Behaviour |
|---|---|
| Dapp reloads mid-send | Dapp on reload has no in-flight state. User retries → fresh msgId, all chunks re-sent. Wallet's partial buffer for the old msgId expires via TTL. |
| Wallet reloads mid-receive | Subscription filter has no since clause, so on reconnect the relay re-delivers all events addressed to the wallet. Chunks reassemble fresh. Works as long as the chunks are still within the relay's retention window. |
| Network blip / all relays reject a chunk | Promise.allSettled on publish treats each chunk identically to any other single message. If all relays reject, publishMessage throws and emitDisconnect fires — same posture as today's sign-request failure. |
| Relay prunes mid-reassembly | Receiver's partial times out via TTL. Application sees no response; user retries — same failure mode the protocol already has for any lost sign request. |
No persistence layer, no per-chunk ACKs, no new round trips. The assembled ProtocolMessage's
own response (e.g. sign_transaction_response) is the effective end-to-end ACK.
Backward compatibility¶
| Dapp | Wallet | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Old | Old | Unchanged. Oversized message fails at nostr-tools with the raw NIP-44 error. |
| New | Old | Dapp detects absent chunk capability and throws a clear upgrade-guidance error instead of the cryptic NIP-44 error. |
| Old | New | Wallet detects absent chunk capability and throws a clear error symmetrically. |
| New | New | Both advertise, both enable, oversized messages chunk-and-reassemble transparently. Application code is unchanged. |
Upgrading the library on both sides is sufficient — no adapter-interface changes, no new configuration, no capability opt-in. The extension is always-on when supported.